Logo

CritifyHub

Home Reviews Blogs Community Movie Suggestions Movie Room Sign in
Sweet Smell of Success Poster

Title: Sweet Smell of Success

Year: 1957

Director: Alexander Mackendrick

Writer: Ernest Lehman

Cast: Burt Lancaster (J.J. Hunsecker), Tony Curtis (Sidney Falco), Susan Harrison (Susan Hunsecker), Martin Milner (Steve Dallas), Jeff Donnell (Sally),

Runtime: 97 min.

Synopsis: New York City newspaper writer J.J. Hunsecker holds considerable sway over public opinion with his Broadway column, but one thing that he can't control is his younger sister, Susan, who is in a relationship with aspiring jazz guitarist Steve Dallas. Hunsecker strongly disapproves of the romance and recruits publicist Sidney Falco to find a way to split the couple, no matter how ruthless the method.

Rating: 7.598/10

The Bitter Perfume of Ambition: Decoding Sweet Smell of Success

/10 Posted on July 19, 2025
In Alexander Mackendrick’s *Sweet Smell of Success* (1957), the neon-lit underbelly of 1950s Manhattan pulses as a character in its own right, a glittering stage for a morally corrosive dance of power and betrayal. The film’s genius lies not in a sprawling narrative but in its razor-sharp screenplay by Clifford Odets and Ernest Lehman, which slices through the veneer of glamour to expose the raw mechanics of ambition. Every line crackles with subtext, as if the words themselves are complicit in the characters’ schemes. The dialogue, delivered with venomous precision, feels like a weapon wielded most devastatingly by Tony Curtis as Sidney Falco, a press agent slithering through New York’s power corridors, and Burt Lancaster as J.J. Hunsecker, a gossip columnist whose influence is both throne and guillotine.

Curtis’s performance is a revelation, shedding his matinee idol sheen to embody Falco’s desperate, almost feral hunger for success. His charm is a mask, slipping just enough to reveal the panic beneath. Lancaster, meanwhile, imbues Hunsecker with a chilling restraint, his soft-spoken menace more terrifying than any outburst. Their interplay predator and prey locked in a symbiotic spiral anchors the film’s psychological depth. Mackendrick’s direction masterfully amplifies this tension, using tight framing and claustrophobic compositions to mirror the characters’ entrapment. James Wong Howe’s cinematography transforms New York into a noir labyrinth, its glossy surfaces reflecting the characters’ distorted desires. The interplay of light and shadow, especially in scenes like the rain-slicked confrontation outside the 21 Club, is a visual poem of moral decay.

Yet, the film isn’t flawless. The secondary plot involving Hunsecker’s sister Susan feels underdeveloped, her passivity a stark contrast to the film’s otherwise dynamic energy. While this choice underscores her vulnerability, it risks reducing her to a narrative device, a rare misstep in an otherwise taut script. Elmer Bernstein’s jazz-infused score, however, is a triumph, its restless rhythms echoing the city’s pulse and the characters’ unyielding drive. *Sweet Smell of Success* endures not for its plot but for its unflinching portrait of ambition’s cost, where every victory is laced with betrayal. It’s a film that lingers, its bitter aftertaste a reminder of the human toll of power.
0 0